Bay Or Holliday?

Jeff Zachowski over at Hotstove NY, made a great chart comparing Jason Bay against Matt Holliday. Yesterday it was reported that the Mets did extensive research on both players, and found that Bay would be better for GHMP. The chart below contradicts what the Mets reportedly believe.

Personally, I would much rather have Bay than Holliday, but according to Zachowski, the Mets information is either wrong, or once again the Mets are trying to sell their fans so they can sell tickets.

Admittedly, I would be happy to see Bay patrolling LF. Holliday played most of his career in Colorado, and any stats from Colorado have to be taken with a grain of salt, humidor or not.